<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.2 20190208//EN" "JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" dtd-version="1.2" article-type="other">
<front>
<journal-meta>
<journal-title-group>
</journal-title-group>
<publisher>
<publisher-name/>
</publisher>
</journal-meta>
<article-meta>
</article-meta>
</front>


<body id="body">
    <p id="_paragraph-2">
      <bold id="_bold-1">Literature Study of Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm for Batik Classification</bold>
    </p>
    <p id="_paragraph-3">
      <bold id="_bold-2">Nardianti Dewi Girsang<sup id="_superscript-1">1*</sup></bold>
    </p>
    <p id="_paragraph-4">
      <italic id="_italic-1"><sup id="_superscript-2">1</sup>Universitas Medan Area, Indonesia</italic>
    </p>
    <p id="_paragraph-5"><italic id="_italic-2"><sup id="_superscript-3">1</sup></italic>nardiantidewigirsang@gmail.com</p>
    <table id="_table-1">
      <tbody>
        <tr id="table-row-8fa5138dc2ff0adccb2a9363eba26483">
          <th id="13cc9d4d42bbad6adb5d89f7bd6df84a">
            <graphic xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="media/image1.png"/>
            <p>
              <bold>*Corresponding Author</bold>
            </p>
          </th>
          <th id="3e29cac9f3035e52f65971823027a392">
            <title>ABSTRACT</title>
            <p>Batik is a hereditary cultural heritage that has high aesthetic
      value and deep philosophy. Currently, Indonesian batik has various
      types of different motifs and patterns, which are spread in
      Indonesia with their names and meanings. Batik classification uses
      Convolutional Neural Network as a pattern recognition method,
      especially batik image classification. The method used is a
      literature study, looking at studies from several journals
      regarding the Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm in
      Classification and providing conclusions about the usefulness of
      the algorithm. Analysis This literature study analyzes each
      journal from previous research related to the Convolutional Neural
      Network Algorithm in classifying Batik. The results of the
      analysis, conducted a discussion to better know the
      characteristics and application of Convolutional Neural Network in
      the classification of Batik. After discussing, this analysis ends
      with conclusions about the Convolutional Neural Network algorithm
      in classifying Batik. Based on previous studies, it can be seen
      that the convolution neural network can work well for image
      classification with large datasets. By evaluating the method that
      has been described by considering the architecture and the level
      of accuracy, namely getting an accuracy level of 100% with an
      image size of 128 x 128 and regarding the classification of batik,
      it shows that image size, image quality, image patterns affect the
      batik classification process.</p>
          </th>
        </tr>
        <tr id="table-row-27482193ba34422bab250d4cc4c8def9">
          <td id="ba4f7def5034d675eb85c88f17c36b2e">
            <p>
              <bold>Article History:</bold>
            </p>
            <p>Submitted: 2021-08-27</p>
            <p>Accepted: 2021-09-04</p>
            <title>Published: 2021-09-04</title>
          </td>
          <td id="77882c380d986809b8a4ff2bb99a839e"/>
        </tr>
        <tr id="table-row-9b10db54e6793653bc16357339245ff4">
          <td id="6eab54573059d08ddd8212f76e2ac271">
            <title>Keywords: </title>
            <p>Deep Learning; Convolutional Neural Network; Heritage;
      Cultural; Batik</p>
          </td>
          <td id="e6010abb26ee618289725b741d82607c"/>
        </tr>
        <tr id="table-row-3476bc46409ffdbf387db0ac5b143f1d">
          <td id="c90cb897251b5b23ae128b34a5b1fc7d"><bold id="_bold-3">Brilliance: Research of Artificial Intelligence</bold> is licensed under a <ext-link id="_external-link-1" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/">Creative      Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC      4.0).</ext-link></td>
          <td id="03297a6cb1981afa7183579925ac41c7"/>
        </tr>
      </tbody>
    </table>
    <sec id="section">
      <title/>
    </sec>
    <sec id="introduction">
      <title>INTRODUCTION</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-6">Batik is one of the cultural icons from Indonesia that has received  an award as a cultural heritage from UNESCO on October 2, 2009. Based  on the field of fine arts, batik is a two-dimensional painting, in  which cloth is the painting medium. Batik has a high value and  charisma. Various kinds of batik motifs have been produced from generation to generation, where the motif contains the meaning of the  ancestors who have animism and dynamism <ext-link id="_external-link-2" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://ejournal.uin-suka.ac.id/saintek/icse/article/view/2904">(Girsang  &amp; Muhathir, 2021)</ext-link>. In another sense, batik is a form of  visual art from Indonesia which is produced using traditional drawing  techniques on materials. For the Javanese, batik is a traditional  cloth that is integral to their cultural identity. Currently, there  are hundreds of batik cloth motifs scattered in Indonesia which  sometimes have their names and meanings. The motif of batik is based  on the shape and pattern of the painting depicted. The number of batik  patterns in Indonesia makes it difficult to identify motifs,  especially for ordinary people. The existence of a method to  facilitate the introduction of batik patterns certainly has many  benefits. One method that can be used is to classify images in  computer-based batik by utilizing artificial intelligence <ext-link id="_external-link-3" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://lenteradua.net/jurnal/index.php/jnanaloka/article/view/2">(Mawan,  2020).</ext-link></p>
      <p id="_paragraph-7">Artificial intelligence has been studied by philosophers for years.  This makes Artificial Intelligence (AI) try to build intelligent  entities that are following human understanding. Artificial  intelligence is a branch of computer science that covers a fairly  large field of science, one of which is machine learning  (<ext-link id="_external-link-4" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://ejurnal.stmik-budidarma.ac.id/index.php/mib/article/view/2997">Prahartiningsyah  &amp; Kurniawan, 2021</ext-link>). Machine learning is a method used  to create programs that can learn from data. Where machine learning is  an implementation of AI. Machine learning itself focuses on developing  computer programs that can teach themselves to grow and change when  given new data  (<ext-link id="_external-link-5" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://jurnalti.polinema.ac.id/index.php/SIAP/article/view/344">Qudsi,  Asmara, &amp; Syulistyo, 2019</ext-link>).</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-8">Pattern recognition is a process for retrieving and classifying  data, where the data can be in the form of images, writing, sounds,  numbers, and others. Pattern recognition is one of the fields that  focuses on the method of classifying objects into certain classes to  solve certain problems. Pattern recognition also has several kinds of  processes, namely, image retrieval, preprocessing used to remove  noise, feature extraction, and classification. Thus, pattern  recognition is widely used as data classification  (<ext-link id="_external-link-6" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://semnaslppm.ump.ac.id/index.php/semnaslppm/article/view/199">Umam  &amp; Handoko, 2020</ext-link>).</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-9">Classification can be used in several fields such as machine  learning, deep learning, and artificial intelligence. The trend in  deep learning has increased in the last 10 years. Therefore, the use  of classification in deep learning is expected to find high  accuracy/results. The classification process cannot be separated from  the data used, either in the form of text or images (image  processing). However, if you use image processing, there are image  dimensions. According to the KBBI, dimension is a measure that  includes length, area, height, width, and so on. Therefore it is  necessary to research whether the dimensions affect the classification  process  (<ext-link id="_external-link-7" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://jurnal.una.ac.id/index.php/jurti/article/view/1342">Kusrini,  Mawan, &amp; Fatta, 2020</ext-link>)</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-10">Deep Learning is part of Machine Learning which consists of many  layers (hidden layer) and forms a stack, the layer is an algorithm or  method that performs the classification of inputted commands to  produce output. One of the developing Deep Learning methods is the  Convolutional Neural Network. This network uses input in the form of  an image, then it will go through a convolution layer and be processed  based on the specified filter, each layer produces a pattern from  several parts of the image that facilitates the classification process  (<ext-link id="_external-link-8" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://journals.ums.ac.id/index.php/emitor/article/view/6236">Nurfita  &amp; Ariyanto, 2018</ext-link>).</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-11">Convolutional Neural Network is an algorithm that has become  popular since the ImageNet 2012 classification benchmark competition.  Until now, CNN has been the choice for methods that use image data as  input because of its good performance. Several introductions related  to writing recognition have been carried out with average accuracy  results obtained above 80%  (<ext-link id="_external-link-9" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://openlibrary.telkomuniversity.ac.id/pustaka/156876/pengenalan-aksara-jawa-dengan-menggunakan-algoritma-convolutional-neural-network.html">Pradhana,  Untari Novia Wisesty S.T., &amp; Febryanthi Sthevanie S.T.,  2020</ext-link>). Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) is one of the  advanced algorithms owned by the neural network and has a good model  class for recognizing handwritten text. The neural network works like  the human brain, which can be trained to increase its knowledge to get  high accuracy. By analyzing each image pixel and matching it with  existing data, this method is suitable for damaged documents and text.  Neural networks are ideal for specific problems such as stock market  data or finding trending image patterns, so far the neural network is  the most efficient method compared to other methods  (<ext-link id="_external-link-10" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://journal.uc.ac.id/index.php/JUISI/article/view/491">Susilo,  Wonohadidjojo, &amp; Sugianto, 2017</ext-link>).</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-12">Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) or commonly called ConvNet, CNN  extracts features from input in the form of images and then changes  the dimensions of the image to be smaller without changing the  characteristics of the image. CNN consists of neurons that have  weights and biases. Each neuron receives input and is forwarded by  doing a dot multiplication on each of these neurons. In the last  layer, CNN still has a loss function like SVM/Softmax. By using an  image sensor such as a camera, the effort used to prepare the device  is much easier, for example, as almost everyone now has a camera  device on a smartphone  (<ext-link id="_external-link-11" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://repository.telkomuniversity.ac.id/pustaka/161870/pengenalan-bentuk-tangan-dengan-convolutional-neural-network-cnn-.html">Ersyad,  Ramadhani, &amp; Arifianto, 2020</ext-link>). Convolutional neural  network algorithms are very popular among deep learning because the  most important factor is in terms of eliminating feature extraction  that can be trained according to the suitability of the task to  recognize new objects that are likely to build an existing network. In  addition, CNN has several other models, namely CNN with 1 conventional  layer, CNN with 2 layers, CNN with 3 layers, and CNN with 4 layers  (<ext-link id="_external-link-12" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://www.jcomputers.us/index.php?m=content&amp;c=index&amp;a=show&amp;catid=225&amp;id=2987">Omori  &amp; Shima, 2020</ext-link>).</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-13">Batik classification uses Convolutional Neural Network as a pattern  recognition method, especially batik image classification. The  Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) method uses a deep learning model  which can carry out an independent learning process for object  recognition, object extraction, and classification and can be applied  to high-resolution images that have a nonparametric distribution  model. The application of the CNN method is used to recognize batik  patterns. Classification using Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm.  The method used is a literature study, looking at studies from several  journals regarding the Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm in  Classification and providing conclusions about the usefulness of the  algorithm.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="literature-review">
      <title>LITERATURE REVIEW</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-14">Several studies have been conducted using the Convolutional Neural  Network Algorithm method which has been applied to batik  classification research. In a study  (<ext-link id="_external-link-13" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://jtiulm.ti.ft.ulm.ac.id/index.php/jtiulm/article/view/62">Maulida,  2021</ext-link>) that discusses the Classification of Typical Batik  Fabrics and Sasirangan Typical Fabrics Using the Convolutional Neural  Network Method, it was found that this study resulted in the CNN  method having two stages, namely, image classification with  feed-forward and carrying out learning stages which were at the  learning stage. CNN applies the backpropagation method. The  classification process carried out must go through a preprocessing  which applies wrapping and cropping methods intending to focus objects  to be classified. Then do the training using the feed-forward and  backpropagation methods. And the final stage is the classification  stage by applying the feedforward method whose weight and bias values  ​​have been updated. After doing these results, the results obtained  an accuracy of 91.84% when trained by conducting random data with 20  epochs and when testing data with 10 random data, the accuracy results  obtained as much as 99.73%.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-15">In a study  (<ext-link id="_external-link-14" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://jik.htp.ac.id/index.php/jik/article/view/144">Fonda,  Irawan, &amp; Febriani, 2020</ext-link>) that discussed the  Classification of Riau Batik by Using the Convolutional Neural  Network, it was found that this study produced Riau batik and not Riau  batik with an accuracy of 65%. The accuracy of 65% is because many of  the motifs are the same between Riau batik and other batiks, with the  difference being in the color of the cerap in Riau batik.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-16">In a study  (<ext-link id="_external-link-15" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://journal-computing.org/index.php/journal-sea/article/view/47">Bowo,  Syaputra, &amp; Akbar, 2020</ext-link>) that discusses the application  of the Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm for Classification of  Solo Batik Image Motifs, it was found that this research resulted in  the creation of a data classification model for the image of solo  batik motifs that had been successfully carried out using a deep  learning method with Convolutional architecture. Neural Network (CNN).  The CNN model in this study uses an input shape measuring 32x32x3,  filter size 3x3, the number of epochs is 100. The data used for the  model training process is 2256 resulting in an accuracy level of  training and testing in detecting images of batik solo images of 99 %  for accuracy and 94% for accuracy validation. This study uses new  testing data of 745 images where per class there are 96 to 127 images  to be tested into the model that has been made. The results of the  testing resulted in a new level of accuracy in classifying the motifs  of the solo batik image, which was 95%.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="method">
      <title>METHOD</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-17">The method related to this analysis, Study literature is a review  of related literature. Therefore, the literature review serves as a  review of the literature (research reports, etc.) on related issues,  which do not always have to be identical to the problem area at hand  but also include those that are frequent and related. Analysis This  literature study analyzes each journal from previous research related  to the Convolutional Neural Network Algorithm in classifying Batik.  The results of the analysis, conducted a discussion to better know the  characteristics and application of Convolutional Neural Network in the  classification of Batik. After discussing, this analysis ends with  conclusions about the Convolutional Neural Network algorithm in  classifying Batik.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-18">The system designed to solve batik images in solving classification  problems uses Convolutional Neural Network (CNN). The batik image  classification system offered in this research has a design with two  phases, the first is the training phase, this phase is system training  to get the model used to classify the image and the second is the  testing phase, this phase is used to test the trained model. using new  data outside of training data. In the training phase, the data and  class labels are used as input in the proposed CNN system. From the  results of the training, a classification model will be obtained that  will be used in the testing phase. Testing data is used as input into  the model and class predictions are obtained. The research method is a  research procedure and technique. Between one study and another, the  procedures and techniques will differ.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-19">Broadly speaking, the classification process using the CNN  Algorithm starts from collecting data in the field. The data is used  as a dataset for the training and testing process. The preprocessing  process is then carried out by designing the CNN Algorithm model and  followed by testing the model. After the model is tested, the accuracy  will be obtained. The final stage is to test the CNN algorithm using  the Confusion Matrix  (<ext-link id="_external-link-16" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://e-journal.unipma.ac.id/index.php/doubleclick/article/view/8188">Ihsan,  2021</ext-link>).</p>
      <graphic id="_graphic-1" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="media/image2.png"/>
      <fig id="figure-panel-103d8f12b5d285ec10ca330e3f47e0d7">
        <label>Figure 1</label>
        <caption>
          <title>Classification Process Using CNN</title>
          <p id="paragraph-3110ad4ad9c4c4f7068d4c43754b987c">Fig. 1 Classification Process Using CNN</p>
        </caption>
        <graphic id="graphic-19afc5ac8fc86ca1f6ba1f0593d4285c" mimetype="image" mime-subtype="png" xlink:href="https://jurnal.itscience.org/index.php/brilliance/article/download/1069/757/3485"/>
      </fig>
      <p id="_paragraph-20">Fig. 1 Classification Process Using CNN</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-21">
        <bold id="_bold-4">Data Collection</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-22">The data collection method used to obtain the image of batik is by  retrieving/downloading via google, or taking data directly. From this  data, samples were taken to be used as training data and test  data.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-23">
        <bold id="_bold-5">Data Split</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-24">The data collected is then divided into two parts, namely test data  and training data, each of which has two classification classes,  namely normal data classification and abnormal data with a certain  percentage. The test data will be used in the model training process  while the training data will be used in the testing process after the  model is formed.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-25">
        <bold id="_bold-6">Pre-Process</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-26">Before conducting training, the data must first be processed or  prepared, the data is prepared by changing the size of the data to  pixel size and converting the image to grayscale because the  classification will focus on the shape of the data, not on the color  of the data, this process is also useful for reducing the learning  load during the training process done.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-27">
        <bold id="_bold-7">CNN Design</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-28">In this process, it is determined the number of layers used, the  type of activation, the number of batches, the number of epochs, the  size of the convolution, the size of the pooling, and several other  parameters needed.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-29">
        <bold id="_bold-8">CNN Classification (Train)</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-30">In this process, the prepared data will be used to perform with a  predetermined class, namely normal data and abnormal data, and will  produce a model. This model will then be used in testing and if it  proves good it can be implemented.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-31">
        <bold id="_bold-9">Test</bold>
      </p>
      <p id="_paragraph-32">This process will test the model that has been previously generated  and then tested with the test data that has been prepared. This test  data will represent new data that will be generated by the system  aiming to check the level of accuracy in the actual implementation.  The final stage is testing the CNN algorithm using the Confusion  Matrix.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="result">
      <title>RESULT</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-33">The dataset used in this study is a dataset of batik images  collected from various sources, such as offline stores and batik  craftsmen, as well as from online stores and online search engines.  The collected dataset is then converted into an image in jpg format.  This data is divided into two classes, namely the abnormal data class  and the normal data class. Abnormal data and normal data are presented  in visual form to make it easier for users to read the information  that has been processed from data obtained from batik. Next is Data  Processing. Training is carried out using training data for normal  data classes and data for abnormal data classes. This data will then  be split back into 70% for training and 30% for validation. The  training will use 2 convolutions with a size of 3x3 and a pooling of  2x2, a layer with ReLU (Rectified Linear Unit) as the activation  function, 10 epochs with a batch size of 16. Different epochs will  result in different accuracy and loss. Next is testing, the model that  has been built previously will be tested with test data to see its  accuracy.</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-34">Table 1</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-35">Convolutional Neural Network Study Literature Results</p>
      <table id="_table-2">
        <tbody>
          <tr id="table-row-bd30012eb915449480b6f1caf7c6d629">
            <th id="86fe0983eff4be912c467f440a0d86aa">Writer</th>
            <th id="9ef46ef6eba93daf05eb073305f5ab57">
              <bold id="_bold-10">Title</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="7d3d785fed521c62e28550600bb747cd">
              <bold id="_bold-11">Architecture</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="a15e1821b54775886b123c5725230f03">
              <bold id="_bold-12">Image size</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="bea7a2bcf25ca48d4e91334b8556b8c1">
              <bold id="_bold-13">Accuracy</bold>
            </th>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-c09a608322daa78f4bdc6abd4eeffd19">
            <td id="1f1b2cc7788f20252614c887fc7f5333">(<ext-link id="_external-link-17" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://iptek.its.ac.id/index.php/jos/article/view/2846">Wicaksono,        Suciati, Fatichah, Uchimura, &amp; Koutaki,        2017</ext-link>)</td>
            <td id="630c33699f740a6b8934e5c9d028d0cb">Modified Convolutional Neural Network Architecture for Batik        Motif Image Classification</td>
            <td id="638c05dcbc6e0da9529978425c5f9a50">CNN IncRes Network</td>
            <td id="5abb6064325cd8fd90de9cf529401476">256 × 256</td>
            <td id="9e9c2728e95c48b2d9e6d373c6ebee9f">70,84%</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-7aaba5bd84d978563306ca3d4039af76">
            <td id="4e303c44209b9de7b7f018f4776505f2">(<ext-link id="_external-link-18" ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://beei.org/index.php/EEI/article/view/2385">Rasyidi        &amp; Bariyah, 2020</ext-link>)</td>
            <td id="14344ca415906d85756674e11ec0d4df">Batik pattern recognition using convolutional neural        network</td>
            <td id="b3d95c62fb795738498286b28762f398">CNN DenseNet Network</td>
            <td id="c3b5438f37a9ee06b3511ca873340eda">-</td>
            <td id="3be63c812f053fc3bce750832cbbd86f">94% and 99%</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-92641c4043072dcebfe60d4a4a09d995">
            <td id="795d4d64db8667dbdd4856153f39f89b">(Handayani, Rasyidi, &amp; Aziz, 2021)</td>
            <td id="a2f592c6dffa8af315340151472f084d">Identification of batik making method from images using a        convolutional neural network with a limited amount of data</td>
            <td id="47d8ade9bda82cd7949774f1c6ae6a05">ResNet, DenseNet, and VGG Networks</td>
            <td id="a5f58681e6982bcadce992fe481d92bc">540 x 630</td>
            <td id="9167d01d4bf45fa6660a9566759e7a86">79.17% and 87.61%</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-86af935b50718cd33f921bbc72ff4964">
            <td id="84c499af3b505ed5aa451af6117c1d41">(Tristanto, Hendryli, &amp; Herwindiati, 2018)</td>
            <td id="aedda52d48cda62425b89daf3529c95f">Classification of Batik Motifs Using Convolutional Neural        Networks</td>
            <td id="b772a0a0f7affd9e20603cbeb6a25311">CNN</td>
            <td id="e64016bb0f362502540a6052ce5a9d69">160 x 160</td>
            <td id="3e98ad82ccc7a9ab5a7aa0166eb04ea6">56%, 91,67%, dan 40-60%</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-553360de032b7122a6017732619f60f6">
            <td id="682e03b1887de8f47a617d6c662c6af2">(Azhar, Mustaqim, &amp; Minarno, 2020)</td>
            <td id="65eb59bd97861d96e27ee0ceb13a11e1">Ensemble convolutional neural network for robust batik        classification</td>
            <td id="5538f9e8ad275be178bc6b11b90bd531">
              <p>Convolutional layers, alternating dropout, and
        max-pooling layers. Classification with 3 (three) fully
        connected layers and combined with the ensemble</p>
              <p>methods.</p>
            </td>
            <td id="bbc8c754b1719ea672939306ca6d5c26">128 x 128</td>
            <td id="7d757ed305ca43bc8b577d6491510cd5">100%</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-deca5c2e4c5794a82a79704c443bc77c">
            <td id="4588b159c64aa5b21bed50d412fb196e"/>
            <td id="0bfc34bed01786a7416a2891ed29c0a5"/>
            <td id="723a8b6cbb558fa42ce647bea21ab9dc"/>
            <td id="80d6aa6b3b28f5c2aa860b85e6a20be3"/>
            <td id="9eaed243836f129284e3d1e86395b02e"/>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-eca95fd8c59e67698c67d06659c9eb94">
            <td id="faa228ed5dbce5ee4b13f36255dc52a8">(Negara, Satria, Sanjaya, &amp; Santoso, 2021)</td>
            <td id="cb98c63548b086ce232aefda028fe7d2">ResNet-50 for Classifying Indonesian Batik with Data        Augmentation</td>
            <td id="8deccd62666ff129a487cd8422bb2baa">ResNet-50</td>
            <td id="22fc1acf3c8ac95001f2a84f2762ac66">-</td>
            <td id="8aee37494b2affa02f901c401f69029e">96%</td>
          </tr>
        </tbody>
      </table>
      <p id="_paragraph-36">Table 2</p>
      <p id="_paragraph-37">Results of Study Literature Classification of Batik</p>
      <table id="_table-3">
        <tbody>
          <tr id="table-row-b90c35e1b0f47df24a5581a7c81aea84">
            <th id="235f3bfc5614474a147083114243bbe9">Writer</th>
            <th id="a52155948d4452fd68cec4f0f6a7729b">
              <bold id="_bold-14">Title</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="6115be4ace9d2d12c955d1d1340e472e">
              <bold id="_bold-15">Purpose Of Paper</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="47825bf4c94b67107e5028692278fa0d">
              <bold id="_bold-16">Conclusion</bold>
            </th>
            <th id="99ad9f739439393c0855b4dde52bfc09">
              <bold id="_bold-17">Suggestion</bold>
            </th>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-09514811daace2cb050cddad4125fb0f">
            <td id="e5af4d3cd881a62dca3f5ada462dc1a0">(Puarungroj &amp; Boonsirisumpun, 2019)</td>
            <td id="bd226542f6980b3d2f0ee8a880c35730">Convolutional Neural Network Models for HandWoven Fabric        Motif Recognition</td>
            <td id="e5f900a648a96c2988954449fb1f20ea">To automate Motive Recognition</td>
            <td id="32568aa25f2c9a78b2d74d00ef1bc0f1">The results show that MobileNets outperformed Inception-v3        with an accuracy rate of 98.223% and 93.208%, respectively.</td>
            <td id="d1c6816c58f5a0cfb8b9177735d44897">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-147bf38aded70ac7ddc2143cfb7619fc">
            <td id="d2c32f123d89e83acc3f041611639a57">(Khasanah, Utami, &amp; Raharjo, 2020)</td>
            <td id="3511fb4e6d8624141e79a3f22a834c1a">Implementation of Data Augmentation Using Convolutional        Neural Network for Batik Classification</td>
            <td id="8b17af322456ecda409ddc997045a96e">Applying 8 types of data augmentation to the batik dataset        using the VGG16 pre-training model with the Fine-tuning        method.</td>
            <td id="221a969ebb39ff56d8de95442dbb4ef9">Batik classification with the selection of data augmentation        succeeded in increasing the accuracy by 3.13% from 95.83%        (without data augmentation) to 98.96% (with the selection of        data augmentation).</td>
            <td id="3b85c2aed9ec77e04ec04f874d59c5c7">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-3b9b0b0567c643a120bfb04fdda77df2">
            <td id="5b3e4924cb5875f0ea96181f9f347635">(Prasetyo &amp; Akardihas, 2019)</td>
            <td id="a7030870afe2aeb62bff299e748811df">Batik Image Retrieval Using Convolutional Neural        Network</td>
            <td id="763345b0a0042e7f60bc74ea6cb1c58a">The use of convolutional neural networks to carry out CBIR        tasks to solve problems that occur in batik image        retrieval.</td>
            <td id="4360ae3345a3927768d505e98228e9de">This system achieves retrieval accuracy of 99.47% and        76.54%, respectively, while the image features are built from        deep learning architecture based on CNN and CAE on the Batik        image database.</td>
            <td id="4b7773921d368414f752b10d64ec6e9e">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-c9eea74442c899f9348652d932cdfd23">
            <td id="aee9d37656dd51b186788b616a57dda0">(Widyantoko, Widowati, Isnaini, &amp; Trapsiladi, 2021)</td>
            <td id="e0d97fbff0e6caacb80675d400aa4d45">Expert role in image classification using CNN for hard to        identify object: distinguishing batik and its imitation</td>
            <td id="c5d07b6006fae324917aaae32e01143f">Identifying Batik and its imitations. And compare two        popular CNN models to classify batik products into five        classes</td>
            <td id="b35ca9e6064f41f8cace821666fa9006">Accuracy results show that models trained with image-based        suggestions perform better than those trained with randomized        images.</td>
            <td id="99227ebd7a64ac9100b2730fc2796986">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-9a6d50ad7aa0e3df06724f5b77c90250">
            <td id="8fad290b49515fc766664f065f4395eb">(Agastya &amp; Setyanto, 2018)</td>
            <td id="24fc5fbd59e280fe86be4e7b414e3f65">Classification of Indonesian Batik Using Deep Learning        Techniques and Data Augmentation</td>
            <td id="618105d2f8cf4c755a4e7df02d6ac911">To recognize batik patterns automatically using the        Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) called VGG-16 and VGG-19</td>
            <td id="c417ba4b8fb65a6717b18472bfb15350">The classifier can give good results because the split image        dataset is enough to make the classifier understand the        important features of the batik dataset.</td>
            <td id="d698a69eb7a9804a0bc5151957b70447">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-ef9a0265c55cd4b16ebef7f4591e719a">
            <td id="5c7617953c7e97d2e4200114eea735be">(Handhayani, Hendryli, &amp; Hiryanto, 2017)</td>
            <td id="bb9b24853d746be5d1b1301b61a2bb9f">Comparison of shallow and deep learning models for        classification of Lasem batik patterns</td>
            <td id="cf1ff18044207a68d94920c803dc6fb7">Explore and compare shallow and deep learning models to        classify Lasem batik motifs automatically</td>
            <td id="8514b389d32256ff24a95541fdd28dbb">Shallow models, particularly supporting vector machines with        linear function kernels perform best, even compared to deep        learning models.</td>
            <td id="0254783f39a1c6fb2f589cedb767dd76">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-966e0c288e0fa01c597f4bc526ff1dff">
            <td id="7973b6008f438c5bc5199d430fe3532b">(Mardani, Pranowo, &amp; Santoso, 2020)</td>
            <td id="648a6c642490b83db66cdff6ba74e899">Deep learning for recognition of Javanese batik        patterns</td>
            <td id="595e35d7fe924da2133e8e13e967f4ca">Classification of batik motif images</td>
            <td id="1f00d1d89fa7ef97e16b7a4db7f9a71f">The test results using cross-validation can achieve an        accuracy of 90.14%. So from the test results, it can be        concluded that deep learning using the CNN method can be used to        classify batik motifs well.</td>
            <td id="d3873e7b73df90dc600052e39b473d43">-</td>
          </tr>
          <tr id="table-row-76f2ac0357751645cbffb0c73d571e64">
            <td id="a0de58eae4918878acd74dc8267e1612">(Minarno, 2021)</td>
            <td id="5f6147c000d8867acb706a45a18ecf1a">Classification of Batik Types Using the Convolutional Neural        Network Algorithm</td>
            <td id="f7ad8d7f9fb7c7713fa3e50766ca5aaa">To prove the proposed model can classify batik images        well.</td>
            <td id="231ca1874647d3d1832308832937bbef">It can be proven that the accuracy obtained using CNN is 98%        and requires faster time than the VGG16 model.</td>
            <td id="03d548f40cd1e9a21a5ca1410390c953">-</td>
          </tr>
        </tbody>
      </table>
    </sec>
    <sec id="discussion">
      <title>DISCUSSION</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-38">Based on previous studies, it can be seen that the convolutional  neural network can work well for classifying images with large  datasets. After conducting this literature study, further research can  use other cases. Like the classification of the Simalungun Shark,  which currently many people do not recognize the type of Shark.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="conclusion">
      <title>CONCLUSION</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-39">The study included in this system shows that the literature on this  argument is focused mainly on the Classification of batik and  Convolutional Neural Networks, the main idea of ​​this method is to  use Convolutional Neural Network to identify batik. By evaluating the  method that has been described by considering the architecture and the  level of accuracy, namely getting an accuracy level of 100% with an  image size of 128x128 and regarding the classification of batik, it  shows that image size, image quality, image patterns affect the batik  classification process.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="references">
      <title>REFERENCES</title>
      <p id="_paragraph-40">Agastya, I. M., &amp; Setyanto, A. (2018). Classification Of  Indonesian Batik Using Deep Learning Techniques And Data Augmentation. <italic id="_italic-3">International Conference On Information Technology,  Information System And Electrical Engineering (Icitisee)</italic>,  27-31.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-11afe548f359e08b371aa757ab071310">Azhar, Y., Mustaqim, M. C., &amp; Minarno, A. E. (2020).  Ensemble Convolutional Neural Network For Robust Batik. <italic id="_italic-4">Top  Conference Series: Materials Science And Engineering</italic>,  1-9.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-29d9fc299222d717c268a041c036a7eb">Bowo, T. A., Syaputra, H., &amp; Akbar, M. (2020). Penerapan  Algoritma Convolutional Neural Network Untuk Klasifikasi Motif Citra  Batik Solo. <italic id="_italic-5">Journal Of Software Engineering Ampera</italic>,  82-96.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-978b73a0469ca2260fdc37b9018579cd">Ersyad, M. Z., Ramadhani, K. N., &amp; Arifianto, A. (2020).  Pengenalan Bentuk Tangan Dengan Convolutional Neural Network (Cnn). <italic id="_italic-6">E-Proceeding Of Engineering</italic>, 8212-8222.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-3322edc230a6816584daf2db4354c044">Fonda, H.,  Irawan, Y., &amp; Febriani, A. (2020). Klasifikasi Batik Riau Dengan  Menggunakan Convolutional Neural Networks (Cnn). <italic id="_italic-7">Jurnal Ilmu  Komputer</italic>, 7-10.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-bb5f0b4cb63b8191e4451b0a344aa88d">Girsang, N. D., &amp; Muhathir. (2021).  Classification Of Batik Images Using Multilayer Perceptron With  Histogram Of Oriented Gradient Feature Extraction. <italic id="_italic-8">Proc.  Internat. Conf. Sci. Engin. 3</italic>, 197-204.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-82b12e008e0cb4e6b5cdb60538aa80f4">Handayani, R.,  Rasyidi, M. A., &amp; Aziz, F. (2021). Identification Of Batik Making  Method From Images Using Convolutional Neural Network With Limited  Amount Of Data. <italic id="_italic-9">Bulletin Of Electrical Engineering And  Informatics</italic>, 1300~1307.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-10c4602d660ae415c000dacd2c06012b">Handhayani, T., Hendryli, J., &amp;  Hiryanto, L. (2017). Comparison Of Shallow And Deep Learning Models  For Classification Of Lasem Batik Patterns. <italic id="_italic-10">International  Conference On Informatics And Computational Sciences  (Icicos)</italic>, 11-16.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-e114df3b85f12dfa76dfb56315862e67">Ihsan, C. N. (2021). Klasifikasi Data Radar  Menggunakan Algoritma Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-11">Journal Of  Computer And Information Technology</italic>, 115-121.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-d6b21204de4b92158ba595fa56e4a4e1">Khasanah, C. U.,  Utami, E., &amp; Raharjo, S. (2020). Implementation Of Data  Augmentation Using Convolutional Neural Network For Batik  Classification. <italic id="_italic-12">International Conference On Cyber And It  Service Management (Citsm)</italic>, 1-5.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-d667d5dc5143f3374937bced6892a3b0">Kusrini, Mawan, R., &amp;  Fatta, H. A. (2020). Pengaruh Dimensi Gambar Pada Klasifikasi Motif  Batik Menggunakan Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-13">Jurnal  Teknologi Informasi</italic>, 218-223.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-59a53d8c2015102233279845cfeda3bd">Mardani, D. A., Pranowo, &amp;  Santoso, A. J. (2020). Deep Learning For Recognition Of Javanese Batik  Patterns. <italic id="_italic-14">Aip Conference Proceedings</italic>.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-172f1904e283f876194cfd66496786fa">Maulida, I.  (2021). Klasifikasi Kain Khas Batik Dan Kain Khas Sasirangan Dengan  Menggunakan Metode Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-15">Jtiulm</italic> , 25-30.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-3b545fbd71f4b8fe7e3e1c2d6e38d087">Mawan, R. (2020). Klasifikasi Motif  Batik Menggunakan Convolutionalneural Network . <italic id="_italic-16">Jnanaloka</italic>, 45-50.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-5fdc8aea712d8d612a6c03fe1a4d7315">Minarno, A. E. (2021). Klasifikasi  Jenis Batik Menggunakan Algoritma Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-17">Repositor</italic>.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-1d031f1be0dbb8ddb3b27b3ebdc513ed">Negara, B. S., Satria, E., Sanjaya, S.,  &amp; Santoso, D. R. (2021). Resnet-50 For Classifying Indonesian  Batik With Data Augmentation. <italic id="_italic-18">International Congress Of  Advanced Technology And Engineering (Icoten)</italic>, 1-4.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-6cda633bcff70a4f94ebfc1a905106ad">Nurfita, R.  D., &amp; Ariyanto, G. (2018). Implementasi Deep Learning Berbasis  Tensorflow Untuk Pengenalan Sidik Jari. <italic id="_italic-19">Jurnal Teknik  Elektro</italic> , 22-27.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-0d2636f0b4cf33e0e6cebca0b8919036">Omori, Y., &amp; Shima, Y. (2020). Image  Augmentation For Eye Contact Detection Based On Combination Of  Pre-Trained Alex-Net Cnn And Svm. <italic id="_italic-20">Journal Of  Computers</italic>, 85-97.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-ef094c69e9b099b7e4e046e3b1b31f2a">Pradhana, S. C., Untari Novia Wisesty S.T.,  M., &amp; Febryanthi Sthevanie S.T., M. (2020). Pengenalan Aksara Jawa  Dengan Menggunakan Algoritma Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-21">E-Proceeding Of Engineering</italic>,  2558-2567.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-c7c96aac338636132d86b6c460878702">Prahartiningsyah, A. A., &amp; Kurniawan, T. B. (2021).  Pengenalan Pola Angka Menggunakan Pendekatan Optimisasi Sistem  Kekebalan Buatan (Artificial Immune System). <italic id="_italic-22">Jurnal Media  Informatika Budidarma</italic>, 856-865.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-2b64980d5cd3538dc70b83b5313d9def">Prasetyo, H., &amp; Akardihas,  B. A. (2019). Batik Image Retrieval Using Convolutional Neural  Network. <italic id="_italic-23">Telkomnika</italic>, 3010-3018.Puarungroj, W., &amp;  Boonsirisumpun, N. (2019). Convolutional Neural Network Models For  Handwoven Fabric Motif Recognition. <italic id="_italic-24">Ecti Damt-Ncon</italic>,  300-303.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-6bd75c475470dc1ab21c1ac9bf688d73">Qudsi, N. K., Asmara, R. A., &amp; Syulistyo, A. R. (2019).  Identifikasi Citra Tulisan Tangan Digital Menggunakan Convolutional  Neural Network (Cnn). <italic id="_italic-25">Seminar Informatika Aplikatif  Polinema</italic>, 48-53.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-cae96bb662fe1d6bd02d39f97dfd705b">Rasyidi, M. A., &amp; Bariyah, T. (2020).  Batik Pattern Recognition Using Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-26">Bulletin Of Electrical Engineering And Informatics</italic>,  1430-1437.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-75d5ae7e74b93b4fd5c7aab91ce17ff7">Susilo, M. M., Wonohadidjojo, D. M., &amp; Sugianto, N.  (2017). Pengenalan Pola Karakter Bahasa Jepang Hiragana Menggunakan 2d  Convolutional Neural Network. <italic id="_italic-27">Juisi</italic>, 28-36.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-e922ac575c5eede53241979b293d16d5">Tristanto,  J., Hendryli, J., &amp; Herwindiati, D. E. (2018). Classification Of  Batik Motifs Using Convolutional Neural Networks. <italic id="_italic-28">International Conference On Information Technology,  Engineering, Science, And Its Applications</italic>, 1-5.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-f1d0df3a7340a63ef4e93152ab66d6ab">Umam, C.,  &amp; Handoko, L. B. (2020). Convolutional Neural Network (Cnn) For  Hiragana Character Identification. <italic id="_italic-29">Semnas Lppm</italic>,  527-533.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-8054338c61fa87bd022373b06cb1e07c">Wicaksono, A. Y., Suciati, N., Fatichah, C., Uchimura, K.,  &amp; Koutaki, G. (2017). Modified Convolutional Neural Network  Architecture For Batik Motif Image Classification . <italic id="_italic-30">Journal Of  Science</italic>, 26-30.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-d99a4b3a1ddf4ce317670ebeef803004">Widyantoko, Z., Widowati, T. P., Isnaini,  &amp; Trapsiladi, P. (2021). Expert Role In Image Classification Using  Cnn For Hard To Identify Object: Distinguishing Batik And Its  Imitation. <italic id="_italic-31">Iaes International Journal Of Artificial  Intelligence</italic>, 93-100.</p>
      <p id="paragraph-6bd0e3e2254d9050d8467eff36b6819a">Yohannes, &amp; Rivan, M. E. (2020).  Penggunaan Global Contrast Saliencydan Histogram Of Oriented  Gradientsebagai Fitur Untuk Klasifikasi Jenis Hewan Mamalia. <italic id="_italic-32">Petir, 13</italic>, 80-85.</p>
    </sec>
  </body><back/></article>
